
It seems you either love or hate Jamie Oliver. I personally bloody love him. Why? Well for one (and for me it is a big one) his literature uses the best typography in the culinary world. Look. At. It.

Design aside, there are of course many other more relevant reasons as well, another being his infectious passion for food and family which makes me fuzzy inside and more importantly inspires people who wouldn't normally cook, get off the freaking sofa and into the kitchen. Which is a good thing in my book. Er, his book.
Jamie's 30 Minute Meals–which accompanies his television series–is a quick cookbook but not, as they typically are, a budget or particularly fat/calorie friendly one. But it is foodie friendly. How about Cauliflower Macaroni with Chicory Salad and Insane Dressing followed by Lovely Stewed Fruit or the one I was drooling at the telly the most - Piri Piri Chicken, Dressed Potatoes, Rocket Salad and quick Portuguese Custard Tarts? All this in 30 minutes? Woo-hoo!
I'm a meal planning geek and he is right; planning the week's meals saves time and money. And coming in a 7pm, I really can only afford 30 minutes, maybe 45 minutes tops for cooking, but I always cook a proper meal. When rushed, I can get out a pretty good poached salmon dish out in 15 minutes and spaghetti puttanesca is always tasty in 12.

Design-wise, this book remains on-brand with the Jamie empire; lots of hands on and motion shots, colourful, saturated and energetic photography. I do love the feel of a Jamie book, he really does invest in considered design and it shows.

The recipe schedule list is good - helping you to multi-task and jump from one recipe part to another. Little video icons are dotted round the book for tricky parts or things that need visual explanation.

As most of the recipes are for 4-6 people, I'm not sure how useful it is for my 2 person household but I guess this book is aimed at the average family unit. Friends are always on hand for feeding round ours so we grabbed two extra mouths to test things out. Food always tastes better with more people around the table anyway!
But the crucial question, and a big question when you set yourself up with a book title like that is DOES IT WORK? Can I get one of these meals down in 30 minutes and still have a little on-the-spot jive and arm wave that he seems to fit in too? The recipes were tested last week on The Guardian's blog with poor results, although I thought reviewed rather unfairly just for the sake of a few comedy quips. So how did my household sensibly fare with the recipes?

For the sake of fairness, I though it shouldn't just be me to test this book out so Mr. Graphic Foodie (a decent cook) took on the Chicken Pie with French Style Peas, Sweet Carrot Smash followed by Berries, Shortbread and Chantilly Cream
Actual time taken: 49 minutes
Things to consider in the time: I have not taken into account the time taken for cutting the fruit for the dessert as Jamie uses berries but being out of season this ingredient would have cost a shocking £8 and so instead we used cheaper seasonal plums, nectarines, pomegranates and oranges which needed preparing. He was also half entertaining our guests too which may have slowed things down a bit.
Result: Rather delicious, homely, comfort food. A proper pie will always take time to prepare but this stripped down version didn't suffer too much from it. Our guests loved the casual cream, shortbread and fruit dessert and the meal overall was given the taste thumbs up.
Mr Graphic Foodie comments: He thought that it was easy to lose your place in the recipe as you were jumping around between items, and read the carrot recipe a bit wrong. He also commented that this recipe could probably be completed closer to 30 minutes with more practice and needed reading through a few times before you started.

The next day I (quite a competent cook *cough*) took on Beef Hash with Jacket Potatoes, Goddess Salad and Lovely Butter Beans and Bacon
Actual time taken: 36 minutes
Things to consider in the time: Although I almost cracked the 30 minutes (I HATE losing), this was not in any way a pleasant pace of cooking. I have cooked a 5 course dinner party for 10 people with more of a steady heartbeat. If I returned from work and cooked with this anxiety, I'd be in the cuckoo house by the end of the week.
Result: Tasty. The butter bean accompaniment was lovely, packed with flavours and the different textures of the whole meal really well considered. This was a happy, fulfilling and delicious family meal and went down well with everyone too.
Comments: Preparation, preparation, preparation. I had all my kitchen and dishwasher doors open so I could keep my workstation clear(ish).

Also the telly program made me drool at the Portuguese tarts so I gave them a go as an extra (not included in the times above). These were really delicious but I did struggle to create the caramel in such a short time and caramel is not something you should be doing with other things on your mind.
So really what I really think of this book is that you shouldn't judge a book by its cover. The recipes in here are gorgeous and prove you can put out a fantastic and exciting complete dinner mid-week that isn't just a plate of pasta or a bowl of soup. However, don't be too rigid with getting it finished in 30 minutes, because you probably won't or if you do you'll be a bit of a wreck. As competent cooks, Mr GF and I almost achieved the time, but those people who Jamie is really targeting, those who may not cook all the time or be very confident, will find this pace too fast.
I'm going to be using this book a lot to pep up my mid-week meals (an relaxed weekend ones too) but I'm not going to be hell bent on producing the recipe in the suggested time scales. I'd say you could create these recipes in 45 minutes to an hour which is time well spent for the results. But I guess that makes a pretty crap title for a recipe book.
I received this (signed-woo!) copy for review.
I've been umm'ing and arr'ing about whether to invest in this Jamie book and after reading this I think I might. His recipes are pretty good - from what I've seen on tv and I think you're right about 45 mins being more acceptable! Your portuguese tarts look fab!!
ReplyDeleteGreat review, much more constructive than the crap guardian blog (sooo negative)...
ReplyDeleteFantastic review Fran - You really tested it in depth, I am tes impressed. Bravo!! But what I really want to know is, being a son of Essex as well - how come I didn't get sent a signed JO book for review? What the hell?
ReplyDeleteHi Fran. A great thorough review! I too tested the book, but as I said in my post I'm not really one for following things to the letter so just did the main course for both of the recipes I tested: feta and spinach filo pie - already blogged: http://feedetgastro.wordpress.com/2010/10/14/jamies-spinach-and-feta-filo-pie/; and (snap) chicken pie, which is yet to be blogged and something I cooked twice since.
ReplyDeleteI agree the recipes are great and totally what you want mid-week. His best book since "Jamie at Home" I think.
Spot on review, 30 Minute Meals is an inspiration point, not "it took 31 minutes so this is rubbish, nyer". It's a way of trying to accomplish as much as you can for dinner in a very reasonable timeframe. I wish people would see past the rigid 30 minute thing.
ReplyDeleteAnd yeah, like Dan as a son of Essex (and Jamie champion!) where's my signed copy?! Unlike Dan I am still here too, I win more Essex points :-)
@Little Welsh - thanks!Yes it really is a good buy.
ReplyDelete@Cook it.. - Ha, yes thanks. I think they are not very pro-Jamie anyway.
@Dan - Me and Jamie, we're like that innit. Maybe it's because you're dropping a load of le Francaise in your lingo.
@Roastpotato Yes absolutely. But to be fair by putting 30 minutes in the title you are lining yourself up for a er, roasting. It is just a fab resource for creating great, complete meals in little time.
@Becci - Ooh missed that one, will have a look!
ps. @Dan and @Roastpotato, I got a free signed copy too! Yeehaaaaar!
ReplyDeleteVery helpful review and I suspect your testing of a number of different meals in the book was much more robust and fairer than that by the Guardian testers.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant review! I know I'll never be able to keep to the 30 mins due to a lack of 1. space, 2. food processor, 3. blender, 4. microwave ... hehe, but the recipes do look great!
ReplyDeleteGreat review, I'm with you, I'm a big fan of Jamie. I wasn't lucky enough to get a review copy but I have been following the tv show. I tried one of the recipes last week - oozy mushroom risotto - http://purelyfood.wordpress.com/2010/10/31/jamies-30-minute-meals-oozy-mushroom-risotto/
ReplyDeleteFab review Fran, love that you got Mr GF involved as well!
ReplyDeleteI agree, the layout of the recipes can be a little confusing. With regards to the 30 minute time frame, although deceptive, I think they just want to highlight that it won't take hours. (who realistically would make a 3-course meal every night anyway?)
The tarts look good... I'll definitely be making them soon.
@kavey Merci. I do like cooking a few things from a book before reviewing. One book I did 6 or so things from.
ReplyDelete@Su-Lin. I don't think you need them but the recipes will take a little longer. I mean how long can it possibly take to cut a carrot!
@Claire Love the TV show!
@GT Yes totally! Yes, Mr GF really found it an issue but to me the layout made sense - maybe because a designer laid it out!!
Great review Fran. I like that you tested it a few times, and I did wonder about whether 30 mins was really possible.
ReplyDeleteI have been checking out many of your stories and i can state pretty clever stuff. I will make sure to bookmark your website
ReplyDeleteWell I've tried 13 out of the 50 recipes, and with exception of a couple of the pasta dishes the 30mins is only achievable by cloning yourself slightly into the future, then hiding your future self in a cupboard for when you need to cook another jamie recipe.
ReplyDeleteAt the moment the 'Broccoli Orecchiette' and the 'Summer Veg Lasagne' are the favourites, with the 'Cheat's Pizza' coming in last in a frisbee fashion.
Agree about the design.
I can't believe how negative the Guardian post is!
ReplyDeleteI'm trying out one of these recipes for the first time, and I've chosen the Broccoli Orecchiette as I've heard great things about it (and it's also the first one in the book). The only trouble is, I will probably get a bit OCD about it and want to cook each meal in turn, without skipping any out.
I have a 2 person household too, but my plan is that by cooking the meals in full, there will be enough to last 2 days with perhaps some spare for lunch as well.
@Tracey I know, very easy to bash something for the sake of comedy. I've now cooked quite a few new bits from it, some just elements and had really good results.
ReplyDeleteGood point about leftovers too!